Dec 20 2011

Which Ones Are Cranes?

Published by at 7:28 am under Cranes,Quiz

When people see a bird that impresses them they often tell me about it.  Sometimes they say, “I saw a crane” and I wonder… was it a crane or something else?   So I’ve made this conundrum into a quiz.

Which of these are cranes?  All of them?  Some of them?  Only one of them?  And which one is non-native?

(The answers are in the comments.)








(photos #1, #2 and #3 by Steve Gosser, photo #4 from Wikimedia Commons)

p.s. As usual I’ll wait to release comments from moderation so that early responders don’t give away the answer.


24 responses so far

24 Responses to “Which Ones Are Cranes?”

  1. Mary Ann Pikeon 20 Dec 2011 at 7:52 am

    Not a bird specialist, but after a quick perusal of Wikipedia I think the birds are:
    1. Great Blue Heron (I see this all the time)
    2. Great Egret (a type of heron, saw one a month ago in Florida)
    3. Hooded Crane?
    4. I think this is a crane for loading/unloading barges, but it might be called something else 🙂

    And, Wikipedia says that Herons are not Cranes, so only 3 & 4 would be Cranes 🙂

    Mary Ann

  2. Joanneon 20 Dec 2011 at 8:06 am

    Blue Heron, Ibis, Sand Hill Crane..

  3. Karissaon 20 Dec 2011 at 8:12 am

    #1 is a Great Blue Heron! I love the one that stops by the pond in my backyard!
    #2 is a crane, but I’m not familiar with the exact name. I saw them on Tangier Island, VA (Chesapeake Bay).
    #3 I’m guessing is a crane.
    #4 is definitely a crane, possibly at a shipyard?

  4. Donnaon 20 Dec 2011 at 8:40 am

    #1 Great Blue Heron; #2 Great Egret; #3 Sandhill Crane; #4 Construction Crane 🙂

  5. Barb Wagneron 20 Dec 2011 at 8:40 am

    I’m taking a stab at this:
    1- Great Blue Heron – Year Round in PA
    2- Great Egret – Migrates in PA
    3- Sandhill Crane – Native to North America, but not PA
    4- Crane Machine – used to lift or lower materials – often found in PA

  6. Claraon 20 Dec 2011 at 8:42 am

    1) great blue heron
    2) some kind of egret
    3) ?
    4) CRANE

  7. mason4saloon 20 Dec 2011 at 9:02 am

    great blue heron

    great egret

    sand hill crane

    crane 🙂

  8. Kate St. Johnon 20 Dec 2011 at 9:34 am

    Barb Wagner & mason4salo have correctly named the species. The first two are herons (not cranes), the last 2 are cranes.

    Non-native is a trick question. Think in/out of North America.

    p.s. Sandhill cranes nest in western PA. (…oh I’ve given too much away!)

  9. Kate St. Johnon 20 Dec 2011 at 9:50 am

    Crane #4 has special talents. It can lift its babies with its “beak.”

  10. Kathyon 20 Dec 2011 at 11:54 am

    Great quiz, Kate. I knew the Blue Heron. I used to have an office in NY across the street from The Blue Herron Gulf Club, and egrets would walk around my lawn when I lived in Florida.

    #4 is the number 1 request by my Grandson to Santa this year, so that one I knew!

    Happiest of Holidays to Everyone, whether you celebrate Hanukkah or Christmas, and Blessings for a Happy and Prosperous 2012.

  11. Glendaon 20 Dec 2011 at 12:22 pm

    #1 Great Blue Heron

    #2 Great Egret

    #3 Sandhill Crane (which I have yet to add to my lifelist)

    #4 A construction Crane

  12. Karen Smithon 20 Dec 2011 at 2:40 pm

    Darn! I had them right but was late posting due to trying to find the migratory pattern of #4! 🙂
    Have you ever, or could you in the future post a discussion/comparison of house finch vs purple finch?

  13. Alex Gruskoson 20 Dec 2011 at 3:14 pm

    so what’s the difference between the two? (herons and cranes) please.

  14. Anne Marieon 20 Dec 2011 at 4:51 pm

    LOL! Kate I loved scrolling down and finding crane #4! You are too funny!

    As an extreme novice bird watcher – I wish I could identify the large heron/crane-ish bird I see at North Park Lake on Saturday mornings… if anyone frequents that area and has seen it, can you let me know… thanks

  15. Kate St. Johnon 20 Dec 2011 at 5:32 pm

    Karen, Crane #4 is non-migratory — a resident of Berlin. He’s the non-native in the bunch. 😉

  16. Kate St. Johnon 20 Dec 2011 at 5:34 pm

    Amazing ESP! Purple vs. House is in the works & will be on the blog after Christmas.

  17. Gintarason 20 Dec 2011 at 7:24 pm

    Kate St. John,

    I didn’t know, that Great Egrets are Herons.
    I’ve taken some photos of Great Egrets past fall:

    I guess, it’s a Little Egret:

    This is a juvenile Yellow-crowned Night Heron:

    An adult:

    Little Egret:

  18. Kate St. Johnon 20 Dec 2011 at 10:11 pm

    >difference between the two? (herons and cranes)
    From Wikipedia:

    The herons are long-legged freshwater and coastal birds in the family Ardeidae. There are 64 recognised species in this family. Some are called “egrets” or “bitterns” instead of “heron”. … Although herons resemble birds in some other families, such as the storks, ibises, spoonbills and cranes, they differ from these in flying with their necks retracted, not outstretched. They are also one of the bird groups that have powder down (down that purposely disintegrates into powder).

    Cranes are a family, Gruidae, of large, long-legged and long-necked birds in the order Gruiformes. There are fifteen species of crane in four genera. Unlike the similar-looking but unrelated herons, cranes fly with necks outstretched, not pulled back.

    — From my own perspective: Herons (and egrets and bitterns) always find their food in water and are always found foraging in water. Cranes spend a lot of time on land and will eat land-based foods.

  19. Geneon 21 Dec 2011 at 11:19 pm

    “Herons (and egrets and bitterns) always find their food in water and are always found foraging in water.”
    One noted exception I know of is Cattle Egrets. They are usually found in open fields. Even riding on the backs of cattle. They are not common in this area though. I very often see them when I’m in to the Dominican Republic.

    ps: I love the Blue Footed Steel Crane by the rivers edge, nice!

  20. Kate St. Johnon 22 Dec 2011 at 7:22 am

    Ooooo, yes, Gene. I forgot about cattle egrets! (50 lashes with a wet noodle for me!)

  21. Lars Muelleron 03 Feb 2012 at 8:12 am

    #4 Grus Metallus Nauticalis

  22. LAon 04 Mar 2013 at 12:49 pm

    For months now I’ve been passing a bird on my way to and from work. At first I thought it was a crane. But something seemed off so I thought maybe a heron. Decided to look up info on the two and after reading an article, thought it had to be the heron. After all, I live in South-Central PA (Franklin County). But then I found this and, really, the bird looks so much more like picture 3 than anything! I never noticed a crook in its neck, but it is also smaller than what I read a crane to be…

    Thoughts? Or other things to look for? Sadly, its in a slightly different spot each time I pass by and the road is not exactly suited for stopping for a longer look…

  23. Janet Lon 08 Aug 2013 at 6:26 pm

    1) great blue heron 2)snowy egret 3) crane 4) crane

  24. Kate St. Johnon 16 Sep 2013 at 10:00 pm

    LA, at long last I found your message and am replying many months late. In Franklin County PA my guesses are: a great blue heron, a great egret (maybe kind of rare), or a green heron (not pictured). My hunch is “great blue”

Comments RSS

Leave a Reply