Category Archives: Songbirds

Seen This Week: Acorns and More

Burr oak acorns, Flagstaff Hill, Schenley Park, 17 September 2025 (photo by Kate St. John)

20 September 2025

There are so many oaks in Schenley Park that a few burr oaks (Quercus macrocarpa) are not noticeable until they drop their large, fringed acorns. Where did they come from? I looked up to find the tree, taller and broader than its neighbors.

Burr oak acorn, Flagstaff Hill, Schenley Park, 17 September 2025 (photo by Kate St. John)

The burr oak’s location does not have a good view so I sat beneath a large oak at the top of Flagstaff Hill overlooking Oakland. Based on acorns, leaves, and the history of landscaping in Schenley Park, my guess is that I sat beneath an English oak (Quercus robur).

(presumably) English oak acorns, Flagstaff Hill, Schenley Park, 17 September 2025 (photo by Kate St. John)

It’s a high mast year for this particular tree. The only way I avoided being hit by acorns was to sit with my back against the trunk!

Other sightings this week include birds Tuesday morning at Bird Lab’s Hays Woods banding which I wrote about on Wednesday’s blog: Hays Woods Birds Live up to Expectations.

Common yellowthroat at Hays Woods Bird Lab, 16 September 2025 (photo by Kate St. John)
Dotted line across the morning sky, Pittsburgh 17 Sept 2025 (photo by Kate St. John)

I rarely walk through the Heinz Chapel Memorial Garden but its fountain is attractive during the drought. On the way to the fountain I found an engraved paver stone with a non-traditional dedication.

Memorialized paver stone at Heinz Chapel, Univ of Pittsburgh, 17 Sept 2025 (photo by Kate St. John)

If you want to find this stone, enter the Heinz Memorial Chapel Garden from the Bellefield Avenue side (near the steps to Bellefield Ave) and look at the pavers along the left. (This photo does not include a view of the Will You Marry Me paver.)

Hays Woods Birds Live Up To Expectations

Female mourning warbler, 16 Sept 2025, Bird Lab at Hays Woods (photo by Kate St. John)

17 September 2025

Yesterday I visited Bird Lab’s banding site at Hays Woods where it was absolutely hopping with birds at the first net check. This is exactly what I’d hoped to see after finding out that Hays Woods gets more birds on fall migration than Bird Lab’s suburban and rural banding sites.

Interestingly, BirdCast predicted that the night before would have Low Migration yet the number and variety of birds banded early yesterday was high. Nick says they have never been able to correlate busy banding days with bird forecast predictions.

Best Bird yesterday was an adult female mourning warbler, pictured at top. My photo isn’t very good so I’m including one from Nick Liadis @bird_lab on Instagram.

Other beauties included American redstarts … (I got to release one of them!)

Female American redstart, 16 Sept 2025, Bird Lab at Hays Woods (photo by Kate St. John)

… a very cooperative white-eyed vireo …

White-eyed vireo, 16 Sept 2025, Bird Lab at Hays Woods (photo by Kate St. John)

… an ovenbird …

Ovenbird, 16 Sept 2025, Bird Lab at Hays Woods (photo by Kate St. John)

… and a common, somewhat secretive warbler in an uncommon pose. Very yellow!

Common yellowthroat, 16 Sept 2025, Bird Lab at Hays Woods (photo by Kate St. John)

When he turns his head it’s easy to see he’s a common yellowthroat.

Common yellowthroat, 16 Sept 2025, Bird Lab at Hays Woods (photo by Kate St. John)

I was so excited about the birds yesterday that I forgot to take a photo of the banding operation so here’s a three year old photo. The operation is essentially the same, but now Nick has 14 mist nets and Shaina, Dana and Kathleen to help.

Nick Liadis and Lisa Kaufman, bird banding at Hays Woods, 7 Sept 2022 (photo by Kate St. John)

Learn more about Bird Lab or schedule a visit to a banding site at birdlab.org.

Support Nick’s efforts with a donation at Bird Lab’s GoFundMe site.

How Do Young Cowbirds Learn To Be Cowbirds?

Immature brown-headed cowbird (photo from Wikimedia Commons)

3 September 2025

The breeding season is over for brown-headed cowbirds in Pittsburgh. The adults courted constantly while the females were fertile but egg-laying stopped in mid-July. By now all the youngsters have fledged and left their hosts to join flocks of cowbirds. These youngsters were raised by another species so how do they know what flocks to join? A new study found out their parents have nothing to do with it.

Parental neglect starts early. Female brown-headed cowbirds (Molothrus ater) are brood parasites that lay their eggs in the nests of smaller birds.  Each cowbird chick is raised, not by its own mother, but by foster parents of another species. Initially the cowbird female lurks near the foster nest to make sure her own egg survives and will sometimes destroy the host’s eggs if her own egg disappears. But after that she’s too busy laying up to 40 eggs per season.

If the biological parents don’t care for it, why doesn’t the young cowbird stay with its host species?

Unlike most birds, a young brood parasite doesn’t get attached to its host parents. You can see this if you rear cowbirds by hand, said Mark Hauber, a comparative psychologist at CUNY Graduate Center in New York: “They start hating you at some point.” If a cowbird imprinted on a family of yellow warblers, say, and sought out warblers’ company as an adult, it would never find a mate and reproduce.

New York Times: How a Parasitic Bird With No Parents Learns What Species It Is

Early studies on how the youngsters discover their own species found that young cowbirds are attracted to the chattering calls of adult females, prefer to associate with birds whose plumage matches their own (immatures and females look similar), and many even hang out with their mothers.

Adult female brown-headed cowbird (photo from Wikimedia Commons)

However, the new study published in ScienceDirect in August conducted DNA tests on groups of immature cowbirds and adults captured together and found that the youngsters always hung out with females but they were never related to them.

Somehow, Chamberlain says, they bump into adult cowbirds and start hanging around them and learning how to behave. But the clock is ticking: By the end of the summer, the juveniles and adults will migrate south. “They have a short time period in which they need to learn these things,” Mr. Chamberlain said.”

New York Times: How a Parasitic Bird With No Parents Learns What Species It Is

Groups of women teach the young. It takes a village to raise a cowbird.

Eastern Kingbird: Don’t Mess With Me

Eastern kingbird (photo from Wikimedia Commons)

29 August 2025

Though eastern kingbirds (Tyrannus tyrannus) are smaller than robins they’re called kings because they win so many battles.

Attacks by Eastern Kingbirds on nest predators such as corvids, raptors, and even large, nonpredatory birds are legendary. Aggressiveness increases the chances that an active nest will fledge young.

Unsuspecting Blue Jays have been knocked out of trees or driven to ground to seek shelter under bushes. Flying crows, all Buteo hawks, Northern Harrier and basically all raptors are attacked whenever they enter kingbird’s defended space.

Birds of the World: Eastern Kingbird Behavior: Responses to predators

When an eastern kingbird is especially annoyed it displays the red crown that’s usually hidden under dark head feathers. This one is thinking about attacking someone maybe a predator, maybe another kingbird, or maybe any bird that dares to enter his territory.

Eastern showing red crown (photo by Stephen Boisvert via Flickr Creative Commons license)

[The kingbird] also uses a particularly startling display during vigorous attacks on humans and presumably other predators. While in steep dive toward predator’s head, an Eastern Kingbird may expose and raise red crown patch and open mouth wide to reveal red gape. The effect is dramatic and has caused at least one human to nearly lose his grip and fall from a tree (M.T.Murphy).

Birds of the World: Eastern Kingbird Behavior: Responses to predators

That’s exactly what Ed McKaveney (@edtechfocus) saw when a kingbird attacked a raven on 10 August. What a great action shot!

The Best 8 Weeks For Pittsburgh Hummingbirds

Ruby-throated hummingbird, immature male (photo from Wikimedia Commons)

24 July 2025

If you’re missing hummingbirds at your feeders this year don’t despair. The best eight weeks for ruby-throated hummingbird (Archilochus colubris) abundance in Pittsburgh has just begun. Juvenile hummingbirds are fledging and migrants will arrive soon to swell the population.

Each brood of ruby-throated hummingbird babies consumes about 9-10 weeks of the female’s time. Beginning with her arrival in Pittsburgh in late April she engages in …

  • Nest building for 6-10 days
  • Egg laying: 2 eggs laid 1-3 days apart
  • Incubation for 12-14 days
  • Hatching: Asynchronous. One of the nestlings is oldest.
  • Nestling phase for 18-22 days until each one fledges.
  • Fledglings fed by mother: 4-7 days
Female ruby-throated hummingbird with nesting material at her nest (photo from Wikimedia Commons)

Egg dates in Pennsylvania range from 9 May to 28 August. There’s enough time to raise two broods.

By late July the first broods are on their own and visiting your feeders. The presence of these juveniles nearly doubles the local population.

Ruby-throated hummingbird, Annandale, NJ, 5 Sept 2012 (photo by Ellen & Tony via Flickr Creative Commons license)

Late next week the first migrating hummingbirds will arrive and further increase the population. You can see them ebb and flow in this animation from eBird Status and Trends.

Ruby-throated hummingbird weekly abundance in North and Central America (animation from eBird Status and Trends)

The Best 8 Weeks has begun! Watch them this summer. They’ll all be gone by the end of September.

Are You Missing Hummingbirds This Year?

Male ruby-throated hummingbird (photo from Wikimedia Commons)

8 July 2025

Some of my friends in the Pittsburgh area have noticed a disturbing lack of ruby-throated hummingbirds (Archilochus colubris) at their feeders this year. “I haven’t seen one since April. They should be here by now.”

Meanwhile other friends aren’t worried at all. Their hummingbird feeder activity is normal. What’s going on?

I pulled ruby-throated hummingbird eBird sightings January-to-June for 2020 through 2025 (inclusive) and put them into the slideshow below. Pick a spot to watch on the map and see it change — or not — as the years pass.

Is your home on or near this map? Are you missing hummingbirds this year? Or not? Leave a comment with your answer.

eBird sightings of ruby-throated hummingbirds in the Pittsburgh area
Jan-Jun 2020-2025

p.s. The 2025 eBird map colors the pin drops red if they have recent sightings. I colored them blue for the slideshow so all years match.

Cool Facts About Catbirds

Gray catbird, May 2012 (photo by Shawn Collins)

18 June 2025

We tend to take gray catbirds for granted but here are some cool facts you might not know. For instance:

  • Gray catbirds (Dumetella carolinensis) are monotypic, the only species in their genus. The catbird’s genus name Dumetella means “small thorny thicket” a reference to his habit of singing from inside thorny thickets instead of from a prominent perch.
Gray catbird (photo from Wikimedia Commons)
  • Males and females look alike except for these subtle differences.

Sexes show similar appearances in all plumages, although females average duller than males and average less-extensive rufous on longest undertail coverts.

Birds of the World: Gray Catbird appearance
  • Catbirds use their sense of smell to find their way on migration(!) as described in this vintage article: Sniffing Their Way North.
  • They are present all year in some parts of the U.S. (purple areas below) but most of us see them only in the breeding season. In Pittsburgh they typically arrive in late April and leave in mid October.
Range map of gray catbird from Wikimedia Commons
  • They nest in the middle of thickets and lay turquoise blue eggs.
Cowbird nest with an egg (photo from Wikimedia Commons)
  • Catbirds are rarely parasitized by brown-headed cowbirds because they recognize cowbird eggs in their nests and kick them out. Note the color! described in this vintage article Cat Versus Cow.
Catbird (blue) and cowbird (speckled) eggs (photo by Chuck Tague)
  • Male catbirds are jazzmen! Their song is an improvisation rather than a direct imitation. Read more at: Virtuoso

Here’s the catbird’s song:

Gray catbird song (recording by Michael Hurben, Xeno Canto #925322)

(video from Wikimedia Commons)

And here’s his “meow.”

Gray catbird meow-ing (Xeno Canto 819785)

Enjoy his song this month. He’ll stop singing soon.

The Only Eastern Warbler That Nests in Holes

Prothonotary warbler (photo by Bettina Arrigoni via Wikimedia Commons)

15 June 2025

Wood-warblers, belonging to the large family Parulidae, are beautiful, dainty birds unique to the Americas. The family has 115 species spread between North, Central, and South America and the Caribbean—56 species can be found in the United States and Canada.

Laura Erickson’s For The Birds

Of those 56 species only two nest in cavities: the prothonotary warbler in eastern North America and Lucy’s warbler in the West.

The prothonotary warbler (Protonotaria citrea) is arguably the most gorgeous of all the wood-warblers with a glowing yellow head and chest and gray wings and tail. As a woodland swamp specialist, he prefers to breed where old trees stand in water and woody shrubs overhang it. A great example of his habitat can be found at Conneaut Marsh–McMichael/Brown Hill Rd in Crawford County, PA.

The prothonotary male arrives in the spring ahead of the females and chooses several potential nest sites. He sings from the opening to claim his territory and attract a mate.

video embedded from American Bird Conservancy on YouTube

He also places moss inside before the females arrive. His lady adds more after she’s chosen one of his sites.

Prothonotary Warbler, nest building (photo by Bobby Greene)

These two are choosing a nest box.

A pair of prothonotary warblers, Conneaut Marsh (photo by Shawn Collins)
A pair of prothonotary warblers, Conneaut Marsh (photo by Shawn Collins)

When the babies hatch both parents feed the young. If undisturbed, the nestlings fledge at 10 days old.

video embedded from Stoil Ivanov on YouTube

Visit woody swamps in June to find him. Don’t delay; this warbler fledges soon.

Range map of prothonotary warbler (from Wikimedia Commons) yellow=breeding, blue=non-breeding

p.s. According to Wikipedia, the Francis Beidler Forest in South Carolina has the densest known population of prothonotary warblers and is currently home to more than 2,000 pairs. A good place to look if you’re nearby.

Elusive Celebrity Warbler Visits Pittsburgh

Connecticut warbler at Bellevue Memorial Park, 24 May 2025 (photo by Steve Gosser)

25 May 2025

On 18 May Chris Lituma reported a Connecticut warbler (Oporornis agilis) at Bellevue Memorial Park. By the end of the week Steve Gosser and I were two of about 100 people who looked for the bird. Many of us went twice. I did.

So a Connecticut Warbler has been hanging at Bellevue Park for nearly a week now. Not only are these warblers not common but they are true skulkers that usually stay hidden. I went over a few nights ago and got to hear him sing but no luck with photos. This evening I went back over and I finally got him after waiting nearly 2 hours for him to pop up. Looking back at my archives, the last one I saw and got pics was back in Sept 2016, nearly 9 years ago! Yes this is a very special bird and so thrilled I got some photos.

Steve Gosser on Facebook, 24 May 2025

A hundred Pittsburgh birders showed up for this warbler because he is rare and very hard to find. Crowd sizes varied. This is the midday crowd on Friday.

Birders looking for the Connecticut warbler at Bellevue Memorial Park, 24 May 2025 (photo by Charity Kheshgi)

Why so many people and why did we come more than once?

Connecticut warblers are skulkers that slowly poke around out of sight in the underbrush and thickets. The male’s song is quite loud and he throws his head back when he sings so the sound bounces off the low canopy.

He’s impossible to find if he’s not singing so if you showed up at 1:00pm on Wednesday, as I did, and the bird is silent and you only have half an hour to wait for him to sing. … Well you’ll have to come back later.

When I returned on Thursday he was singing but it still took an hour to see him. First looks are usually poor but rewarding. Charity Kheshgi visited several times to get a good photograph. Notice how the views improved.

My best view was this one, captured by Ryder Shelley who was standing next to me on Thursday.

And this view is why everyone comes back, over and over again. It takes a lot of luck to see a Connecticut warbler this well. Phillip Rogers was very, very lucky.

As of 7:50am today (25 May) the warbler is still in Bellevue Memorial Park. Someone heard him this morning and is hoping to see him.

Sooner or later the bird will leave for his breeding grounds up north but we won’t know he’s gone until people try for at least a day with no luck.

UPDATE on Tuesday 27 May 2025: The Connecticut warbler is gone. No one has reported it since the afternoon / evening of Sunday 25 May.

Pinyon-Juniper: A Widely Spaced Forest Only 10 Feet Tall

Gunnison River flows through pinyon-juniper forest at Dominiguez-Escalante National Conservation Area (photo from Wikimedia Commons)

Tuesday 22 April 2025: Grouse Lek Extravaganza with She Flew Birding Tours.
Day 4: Colorado National Monument, Coal Canyon, to Craig

Since leaving Denver we’ve driven through some amazing scenery on our way to Gunnison, Colorado on Sunday night and Grand Junction on Monday. We crossed Monarch Pass, were awed by the Black Canyon of the Gunnison, and have passed through mountains, basins and valleys. Today we’ll spend part of our time in pinyon-juniper woodlands, nicknamed “PJ.”

Pinyon-juniper woodland dominates the slopes above the sagebrush and below the ponderosa pines in southern and western Colorado (quote from Colorado Birding Trail). To those of us from Pennsylvania this PJ woodland scene at Dominiguez-Escalante suggests an old field reverting to forest. Nope.

Two people walk through a pinyon-juniper woodland at Dominiguez-Escalante NCA (photo from Wikimedia Commons)

According to the Colorado State Forest Service, the most common PJ tree species are the Colorado piñon pine, the Utah juniper and the New Mexico or one-seed juniper (Juniperus monosperma) that thrive in drought-prone, cold areas where annual precipitation is 10-15 inches. The trees cope with these challenges by growing widely spaced and rarely exceeding 10 feet tall.

Colorado piñon pine (Pinus edulis) [or pinyon pine]
Pinyon pine in Utah (photo from Wikimedia Commons)
Pinyon pine foliage, cones and seeds (photo from Wikimedia Commons)

Pinyon jays (Gymnorhinus cyanocephalus) have such a symbiotic relationship with pinyon pines that these woodlands are really the only place to find them. Unfortunately the jay is declining dangerously and its disappearance could cause the pine to decline as well. In 2023 USFWS began a study to decide whether to list the pinyon jay as Endangered, described in the video below. As of this writing the jay’s status has not changed.

video embedded from KOB 4 TV on YouTube
Utah juniper (Juniperus osteosperma)
Utah junipers in Utah (photo from Wikimedia Commons)
Utah juniper scaled leaves, female and male cones (photo from Wikimedia Commons)

Though juniper titmice (Baeolophus ridgwayi) have “juniper” in their name they do not have the close relationship with junipers that the pinyon jay has with pines. This bird used to be the plain titmouse (he is definitely plain!) but was named for his preferred habitat when he was split from the oak titmouse in the 1990s. His “oak” cousin is well studied but he is not.

video embedded from Badgerland Birding on YouTube

In addition to a “pinyon” and “juniper” species, the Colorado Birding Trail: Pinyon-Juniper Woodland lists the birds that make the area home for at least part of the year:

Bird species that breed almost exclusively in or near pinyon-juniper in Colorado include Black-chinned Hummingbird, Cassin’s Kingbird, Gray Flycatcher, Gray Vireo, Pinyon Jay, Bewick’s Wren, Juniper Titmouse, Bushtit, Black-throated Gray Warbler, Black-throated Sparrow, and the rare but spectacular Scott’s Oriole. In addition, this habitat may host Common Poorwill, Ash-throated Flycatcher, Plumbeous Vireo, Blue-gray Gnatcatcher, and Woodhouse’s Scrub-Jay. In winter it can be crawling with mixed-species flocks of thrushes, including American Robin, bluebirds, and Townsend’s Solitaire.

Colorado Birding Trail: Pinyon-Juniper Woodland

But we’d have to stay throughout the year to see them all.