All posts by Kate St. John

Pinyon-Juniper: A Widely Spaced Forest Only 10 Feet Tall

Gunnison River flows through pinyon-juniper forest at Dominiguez-Escalante National Conservation Area (photo from Wikimedia Commons)

Tuesday 22 April 2025: Grouse Lek Extravaganza with She Flew Birding Tours.
Day 4: Colorado National Monument, Coal Canyon, to Craig

Since leaving Denver we’ve driven through some amazing scenery on our way to Gunnison, Colorado on Sunday night and Grand Junction on Monday. We crossed Monarch Pass, were awed by the Black Canyon of the Gunnison, and have passed through mountains, basins and valleys. Today we’ll spend part of our time in pinyon-juniper woodlands, nicknamed “PJ.”

Pinyon-juniper woodland dominates the slopes above the sagebrush and below the ponderosa pines in southern and western Colorado (quote from Colorado Birding Trail). To those of us from Pennsylvania this PJ woodland scene at Dominiguez-Escalante suggests an old field reverting to forest. Nope.

Two people walk through a pinyon-juniper woodland at Dominiguez-Escalante NCA (photo from Wikimedia Commons)

According to the Colorado State Forest Service, the most common PJ tree species are the Colorado piñon pine, the Utah juniper and the New Mexico or one-seed juniper (Juniperus monosperma) that thrive in drought-prone, cold areas where annual precipitation is 10-15 inches. The trees cope with these challenges by growing widely spaced and rarely exceeding 10 feet tall.

Colorado piñon pine (Pinus edulis) [or pinyon pine]
Pinyon pine in Utah (photo from Wikimedia Commons)
Pinyon pine foliage, cones and seeds (photo from Wikimedia Commons)

Pinyon jays (Gymnorhinus cyanocephalus) have such a symbiotic relationship with pinyon pines that these woodlands are really the only place to find them. Unfortunately the jay is declining dangerously and its disappearance could cause the pine to decline as well. In 2023 USFWS began a study to decide whether to list the pinyon jay as Endangered, described in the video below. As of this writing the jay’s status has not changed.

video embedded from KOB 4 TV on YouTube
Utah juniper (Juniperus osteosperma)
Utah junipers in Utah (photo from Wikimedia Commons)
Utah juniper scaled leaves, female and male cones (photo from Wikimedia Commons)

Though juniper titmice (Baeolophus ridgwayi) have “juniper” in their name they do not have the close relationship with junipers that the pinyon jay has with pines. This bird used to be the plain titmouse (he is definitely plain!) but was named for his preferred habitat when he was split from the oak titmouse in the 1990s. His “oak” cousin is well studied but he is not.

video embedded from Badgerland Birding on YouTube

In addition to a “pinyon” and “juniper” species, the Colorado Birding Trail: Pinyon-Juniper Woodland lists the birds that make the area home for at least part of the year:

Bird species that breed almost exclusively in or near pinyon-juniper in Colorado include Black-chinned Hummingbird, Cassin’s Kingbird, Gray Flycatcher, Gray Vireo, Pinyon Jay, Bewick’s Wren, Juniper Titmouse, Bushtit, Black-throated Gray Warbler, Black-throated Sparrow, and the rare but spectacular Scott’s Oriole. In addition, this habitat may host Common Poorwill, Ash-throated Flycatcher, Plumbeous Vireo, Blue-gray Gnatcatcher, and Woodhouse’s Scrub-Jay. In winter it can be crawling with mixed-species flocks of thrushes, including American Robin, bluebirds, and Townsend’s Solitaire.

Colorado Birding Trail: Pinyon-Juniper Woodland

But we’d have to stay throughout the year to see them all.

Endangered Dance

Gunnison sage grouse displaying in Gunnison County, Colorado, 26 March 2023 (photo by Larry Lamsa via Flickr Creative Commons license)

21 April 2025: Grouse Lek Extravaganza with She Flew Birding Tours.
Day 3: Gunnison sage-grouse lek, Black Canyon of the Gunnison, Fruitgrowers Reservoir, to Grand Junction

The first grouse we’ll see on the Grouse Lek tour is the Gunnison sage-grouse (Centrocercus minimus) a target species for many birders because it is listed as Endangered by the IUCN and its declining population contains only 1,770 to 8,000 adult birds. Ironically the species did not “exist” until 1995 when it was split from the greater sage-grouse (Centrocercus urophasianus).

From Colorado Parks and Wildlife[1]: “In the late 1990’s Colorado wildlife researchers found that the sage-grouse in the Gunnison Basin were unique from the sage-grouse found elsewhere. Named for its home range the bird is:

  • Two thirds (2/3) the size of the greater sage-grouse
  • Has more distinct white barring on its tail feathers, seen from behind during the strut
  • A yellow-green fleshy comb above each eye … and …
  • Long filoplumes that arise from the back of the neck and are tossed up and back during the strut.
  • It also has a completely separate range from the greater sage-grouse.

This map shows the current and the potential ranges both species might resettle if their numbers grew. “As of 2012 the Gunnison sage-grouse inhabited only 10% of its original range”[1].

Greater and Gunnison sage-grouse current ranges and past areas that grouse could resettle (map from USDA Forest Service)

Unfortunately the Gunnison sage-grouse is in trouble. It’s only found in seven isolated locations in Colorado and has one tiny population in Utah. Its range keeps shrinking.

In 2013 US Fish and Wildlife Service proposed listing it as Endangered but feedback from residents, ranchers, local governments, and the oil and gas industry did not want the land use constraints so for now it is listed as Threatened in the U.S.

Today our tour will see the birds from afar at a lek on the crest of a hill. We are privileged to see this endangered dance.

Learn more about the Gunnison sage-grouse in this video from High Country News.

video embedded from High Country News on YouTube

[1] Quotes with the footnote [1] are from a 2012 video by Colorado Parks and Wildlife on YouTube. That video also shows a captive breeding program that was conducted at least a decade ago.

Why a Lek? The Ladies Insist On It

Female greater sage-grouse watch the males perform on the lek (photo from Wikimedia Commons)

20 April 2025: Grouse Lek Extravaganza with She Flew Birding Tours.
Day 2: South and west to Gunnison, birding along the way.

Question of the Day: What is a lek and why do grouse do it?

“A lek is an aggregation of male animals gathered to engage in competitive displays and courtship rituals, known as lekking, to entice visiting females which are surveying prospective partners with which to mate.” — Wikipedia definition of Lek Mating

Male greater sage-grouse on the lek (photo from Wikimedia Commons)

Each species performs its unique song and dance, heavily influenced by female choice. Only the females’ favorite dancers get to mate so those are the traits passed to the next generation.

Let’s take a look at the courtship ritual of the most numerous grouse in the American West, the greater sage-grouse (Centrocercus urophasianus). Notice that his “song” is something like “blub… blub blub.” The ladies hear it and come to the lek.

Greater sage-grouse courtship display (video embedded from American Bird Conservancy on YouTube)

As males and females gather at the lek, the arrangement of individual birds within the arena changes as the strong males challenge and push away the weaker ones. The dominant males end up in the center, weaker ones on the edges (alpha-male is highest ranking, then beta-male, gamma-male, etc).

Greater sage-grouse lek diagram from Wikimedia Commons

After the males’ hierarchy is established the females mate with the dominant male(s) in the center. The ladies invite mating by facing away and tenting their wings.

May 2015 video embedded from PBS Nature on YouTube

Q: Why a lek?

A: The ladies insist on it.

On My Way to Look at Leks

Greater sage-grouse on the lek (photo from Wikimedia Commons)

19 April 2025: Grouse Lek Extravaganza with She Flew Birding Tours
Day 1: Flying to Denver

Though I’ve birded a lot in North America I’ve never seen sage-grouse or prairie chickens and I’ve never seen them courting at their leks. Today I’m filling that gap by joining She Flew Birding Tours for the Grouse Lek Extravaganza in Colorado 19-25 April.

Our tour will be on the road every day and ultimately span Colorado east and west. We’ll visit a wide variety of habitats and elevations from the prairies to mountains to basins. Snow on high and spring on the plains.

6-day route of the Grouse Lek Extravaganza, 19-25 April 2025 (screenshot from Google Maps)
Click on the image to see it in Google Maps

Since I have never been birding in Colorado I stand a chance of seeing 16 Life Birds, shown in the slideshow below.

(Slideshow photos are from Wikimedia Commons -except- all photos of Gunnison sage-grouse are by Larry Lamsa via Flickr Creative Commons license)

In the days ahead I’ll describe how leks work and show videos of the species doing their unique dances.

Tomorrow we head for the Gunnison Basin.

Seen This Week: Sunshine and Flowers

Bent and broken tree leans at Raccoon Wildflower Reserve, 13 April 2025 (photo by Kate St. John)

18 April 2025

Several days were sunny this week so I made sure to get outdoors.

At Raccoon Wildflower Reserve on 13 April I encountered a broken tree which I have seen many times before, but this time it had a shadow that nearly touched the far end. The brightly lit forest floor also shows why wildflowers bloom in April. They are flooded with light before the trees leaf out.

Best Photo of the week, though not a native wildflower. Purple deadnettle (Lamium purpureum) is blooming throughout western Pennsylvania.

Purple deadnettle, Frick Park, 14 April 2025 (photo by Kate St. john)

The day warmed up considerably at Raccoon Wildflower Reserve on 13 April. I could almost watch the flowers opening.

Trout lilies (Erythronium americanum) were just beginning to bloom along the south-facing cliff.

Trout lily, Raccoon Wildflower Reserve, 13 April 2025 (photo by Kate St. John)

Spring beauties (Claytonia virginica) were everywhere.

Spring beauties, Raccoon Wildflower Reserve, 13 April 2025 (photo by Kate St. John)

Sessile or toad trillium (Trillium sessile) was still in bud, though even when it blooms it barely opens.

Sessile or toad trillium still in bud, Raccoon Wildflower Reserve, 13 April 2025 (photo by Kate St. John)

Virginia bluebells (Mertensia virginica) were still in bud on Sunday but they’ll be open today.

Virginia bluebells in bud, Raccoon Wildflower Reserve, 13 April 2025 (photo by Kate St. John)

Beavers have been busy along Raccoon Creek. Unfortunately this tree looks doomed.

Evidence of beavers at Raccoon Creek, Raccoon Wildflower Reserve, 13 April 2025 (photo by Kate St. John)

Next week promises to be warm and sometimes sunny. It’s a good time to get outdoors.

Peregrine Update Southwest PA, 17 April

Ecco arrives to incubate before dawn, 12 April 2025 6:43am (photo from the National Aviary snapshot camera at Univ of Pittsburgh)

17 April 2025

This week there is a wide range of activity at our local peregrine nests, from pairs who began incubating just 1-2 weeks ago to our earliest hatch at the Tarentum Bridge. The big event to watch for is Hatch Day at the Cathedral of Learning next week.

Cathedral of Learning, Univ of Pittsburgh:

Ecco and Carla are nearing the end of incubation so one of them is always at the nest 24×7. Lately Ecco has been arriving before dawn for the first nest exchange of the day as shown at top on 12 April and in this morning’s video below.

Notice that Ecco makes soft squeaky noises as he settles over the eggs this morning. It may be because the chicks inside each egg are old enough to hear him and perhaps respond.

video from the National Aviary falconcam at Univ of Pittsburgh

Watch the National Aviary falconcam at the University of Pittsburgh’s Cathedral of Learning for Hatch Day next week — some time between 22 and 25 April 2025. If you observe them every day you’ll know that hatching is near when Carla refuses to get off the eggs. Mother peregrines always preside on Hatch Day.

Sewickley Bridge, Ohio River:

Peregrine nest exchange at Sewickley Bridge, 16 April 2025 (photo by Jeff Cieslak)
female into nest box (yellow arrow), male leaving

Great news at the Sewickley Bridge! Yesterday Jeff Cieslak confirmed that the pair is incubating when he witnessed a nest exchange and captured photos.

East Liberty Presbyterian Church, Pittsburgh:

At this point it is certain that incubation has begun, perhaps on or around March 26. On 8 April Adam Knoerzer reported on eBird with the photo above:

Female perched on exterior light fixture facing in the direction of Shadyside/Oakland. Male visible while shuffling/readjusting egg(s) during incubation.

Tarentum Bridge, Allegheny River:

Tarentum Bridge nestbox (photo by Amber Vanstein)

They’ve hatched! Dave Brooke reports the female was feeding young in the nestbox on 12 April though the chicks were too tiny to see above the edge of the box. Pretty soon there will be good views from these vantage points.

SUMMARY FOR SOUTHWEST PA:

All potential and existing peregrine sites are listed in the table below BUT YOU HAVE TO SCROLL TO SEE THEM. News is sketchy to non-existent at most sites. For instance, I checked for incubation Downtown on Tuesday 15 April and saw nothing.

Help fill in the blanks by visiting a site near you. Leave a comment if you find anything!

Pigeons Know 4-Letter Words

Rock pigeon closeup (photo from Wikimedia Commons)

16 April 2025

Nine years ago two studies of rock pigeon (Columba livia) brain power discovered that pigeons can tell the difference between a real 4-letter English word and a nonsense collection of four letters.

According to Science Daily,

In the experiment, pigeons were trained to peck four-letter English words as they came up on a screen, or to instead peck a symbol when a four-letter non-word was displayed.…

Eventually the four birds in the experiment recognized 26 to 58 real words and correctly labelled over 8,000 as non-words. 

Science Daily, Sept 2016: Bird brain? Pigeons have quite a way with words

Though they know a real 4-letter word when they see one, they don’t know what it means, so they can’t tell the difference between a good 4-letter word and a bad one.

If pigeons could speak they’d have fowl mouths.

Birds Showing Off, Part 2: Peregrine Falcons!

Gusto flies upside down in courtship with Luna at the Hilliard Bridge, Spring 2025 (photo by Chad+Chris Saladin)

15 April 2025

Ten days ago in Birds Showing Off I blogged about the courtship flights of four raptor species: western marsh harrier, golden eagle, bald eagle and peregrine falcon and included photos of peregrines flying upside down from C&C’s Ohio Peregrine Page on Facebook by Chad+Chris Saladin.

In case you can’t imagine this, Chris posted an amazing series on 10 April of a male peregrine in sustained upside down flight while courting his new mate at Hilliards Bridge. Notice that he twists his head almost 180° so that his vision is rightside up. Wow!

Peregrine in sustained upside down flight
Hilliards Bridge, Ohio, Spring 2025 (photos by Chad+Chris Saladin)

The backstory is awesome, too, quoted from Chris’s post:

We were enthralled and entertained by Gusto and Luna engaging in gravity-defying courtship flights around the Hilliard bridge on a very windy day (30-40 mph winds that would blow our hats off without our hoods up tight over them)! It was tough to stabilize and to hold our cameras still enough to capture it.

We’ve mentioned before that seeing peregrines flying in heavy wind and getting to watch them in the showy courtship mode as they are bonding results in some of the most mind-blowing flight angles and body postures imaginable! And peregrines are amazing enough in flight without the aid of the wind, but when you add in the heavy gusts the speed reaches UNREAL proportions!

They were zipping over and around us, through the bridge arches underneath and then reappearing over our heads with swift ring-ups. They were hanging in the wind nearly motionless, and then with a slight twitch or tuck they would speed by, cutting through the wind, or angling their bodies for a tailwind to push them into overdrive!

You can often see the difference between males and females in flight, with males achieving more adept maneuvers and higher speeds overall. In this case the difference was even more striking, as the experience of maturity showed—although Luna was really moving through the air quickly, it was as if Gusto could fly circles around her!

In this album we’re sharing a sequence of Gusto in flight upside down out over the valley—it was somewhat distant, so we tried not to over-crop this sequence, but we still hope this provides enough detail to show his sustained upside down flight with his head contorted as he was focused on his flight path while flapping and gaining even more momentum! INCREDIBLE!!

C&C’s Ohio Peregrine Page on Facebook

Follow C&C’s Ohio Peregrine Page on Facebook for more breath-taking peregrine news.

When Will New Birds Get Here?

Yellow-throated warbler (photo by Steve Gosser)
Yellow-throated warbler (photo by Steve Gosser)

14 April 2025

Last weekend in Pittsburgh we were reminded that migration really is heating up when at least five rare water birds were present in Allegheny County and Moraine State Park. Birders chased for a glimpse of the barnacle goose (who was on the move yesterday and may have left last night), a flock of red-necked loons in non-breeding plumage, a single red-necked grebe, an arctic tern, and a small flock of American white pelicans on Lake Arthur. There may have been others. The alerts were intense.

And now there’s a selection of early warblers in the area: Louisiana waterthrush, pine, yellow-throated and yellow-rumped warblers.

Now’s the time to start checking birdCast.info to help you find the birds. The tools include:

This morning’s Migration Dashboard for Allegheny County shows that last night was the most intense night so far this spring. We’d been seeing low migration for 12 days, then last night almost a million birds passed overhead. Reality Check: Lots of birds passing overhead often means they didn’t stop here. 🙁

There is also a new tool that tells you the Peak Spring Bird Migration Periods for 1,000 U.S. Cities. This small-size map, embedded from that report, is just a tease for the details you’ll find when you scroll down at this link.

For example, on average peak migration in Pittsburgh is May 7-22.

One more tease: Here’s what we’re looking for.

  • Hooded warbler (photo by Steve Gosser)

Warblers in southwestern PA in early May (photos by Steve Gosser)

Invertebrate of the Year

Collage of Panarthropoda including this year’s Invertebrate of the Year (photo from Wikimedia Commons)

13 April 2025

This year I’ve seen many examples of spineless creatures but who is the best of the invertebrates? The Guardian runs an annual contest to name the Invertebrate of the Year. Let’s see who won for 2025.

First of all, who was in the running?

So 97% of the species on Earth were in competition for the top spot. This is impossibly hard to win for repulsive creatures like leeches.

In fact this year’s winner is microscopic and very cute, an eight-segmented creature with tiny claws that help it walk.

Milnesium tardigradum, Winner of Invertebrate of the Year 2025 (photo from Wikimedia Commons)

Our winner, the 0.5mm-long Milnesium tardigradum, has survived all five great extinction events. It survived in outer space when plonked there as part of a European Space Agency experiment. Tardigrades can endure radioactivity, most cancers, extreme cold, scorching heat, zero gravity, being shot from a gun and being trapped in a freezer for – wait for it – 30 years.

— paraphrased from The Guardian: It’s heroic, hardy and less than a millimetre long: meet the 2025 invertebrate of the year

The secret to its invincibility is that it shrivels into a dehydrated “tun” state under adverse conditions.

Milnesium tardigradum in tun state, seen via electron microscope (photo from Wikimedia Commons)

Just add a little water — years later — and they come right back.

See tardigrades move in this 2009 video from NPR.

2009 Science Friday video embedded from Evoimpertinente on YouTube

Read more about the contest and its winner at the Guardian: It’s heroic, hardy and less than a millimetre long: meet the 2025 invertebrate of the year.

Hungry for more? Here’s 7+ minute video from Animalogic on YouTube: Tardigrades: The Most Resilient Animals in the Universe.