Jun 04 2014

What Made This Tree Fall Over?

Published by at 7:20 am under Quiz,Schenley Park,Trees

Black cherry tree toppled at Schenley Park, 30 May 2014 (photo by Kate St. John)

When I see a tree snapped in half like this I have to ask: What made this tree fall over?

I did some detective work but I don't know the answer yet.  Maybe you can help.  Here are the clues:

  • The tree is a black cherry (Prunus serotina)
  • It was alive when it fell.  It grew leaves this spring so the structural weakness wasn't evident until the tree broke.
  • This is the only broken tree at this location in Schenley Park.  Even if a strong wind snapped the trunk it wasn't strong enough to damage other trees.
  • The trunk is not hollow inside the break though there are air gaps between the light outer wood and dark inner core.
  • There's a white flaky substance inside the trunk that coats the light wood layers.  Is it a fungus?
  • Did the white stuff weaken the trunk?  Is it responsible for the break?

The trunk isn't hollow, but...
Black cherry break, 30 May 2014 (photo by Kate St. John)

Here's a close look at the white flaky fungus.  It reminds me of the white correction tape I use on paper.
White flaky fungus. What is it? (photo by Kate St. John)

Do any of you know what this is?  Is it the reason the tree fell over?

Leave a comment with your answer.


(photos by Kate St. John)

UPDATE on June 5 with the ANSWER!   It's a species of Armillaria or honey fungus.  (See Maureen Hobma's comment below.)   Well, I feel a little dumb.  I wrote about Armillaria on 16 January 2014 because I was fascinated that it's the largest living organism.  I even included a photo of the white sheets inside the heartwood but, having never seen the white sheets before, I did not remember them.  Until now I had only seen the black rope-y strands and the honey mushrooms so that's all I knew of Armillaria.  The white sheets are the newer growth, the mycelium, and can be bio-luminescent!   I learn something new every day.

10 responses so far

10 Responses to “What Made This Tree Fall Over?”

  1. Diane Shumakeron 04 Jun 2014 at 8:25 am

    Not sure about this, but could it be heart rot? This would cause damage to inside of tree and a good strong wind would bring it down.

  2. faith ann cornellon 04 Jun 2014 at 9:05 am

    I had a home built in Beaver Co. in the mid-60s and the yard and lot was filled with black choke cherry trees and then we started getting reallly BIG carpenter ants in our basement so we had the
    trees cut down & we were amazed that all of them were hollowed out bec. carpenter ants are extactly what they say, they eat wood and the wood cutters told us that future storms would start to blow these over and damage the house of course. But I do not remember whether the insides had that white paper look. That is interesting though to see why these fell.

  3. Tom Pon 04 Jun 2014 at 12:46 pm

    It’s clearly a fungus hence the white hyphal structure. Looking at the center of the tree you can see that it broke off without lots of fibrous material tearing. That indicates that the wood structure has been digested thoroughly leaving it with no strength. Even tho there was woody material in the center of the tree it was structurally hollow. The white fungus hyphae material is kind of neat. Once pulled a letter paper sized sheet off of a fallen hemlock that had severe ring separation allowing the sheet to form a large continuous expanse.

  4. Kate St. Johnon 04 Jun 2014 at 12:53 pm

    Tom P, do you know what kind of fungus it is? Wish I knew!

  5. Susan Washburnon 04 Jun 2014 at 6:27 pm

    Kate, I suggest you send this to Sandy Feather at the Penn State Extension office. I’m sure she would have an answer for you!

  6. MaryAnn Son 04 Jun 2014 at 8:29 pm

    Call your County Extension Agent, and see if you can email the pictures to him/her. They should be able to tell you, as part of their training is tree/plant diseases. Good pictures!

  7. Maureen Hobmaon 04 Jun 2014 at 10:14 pm

    I am at the CDC for a fungus workshop, I will ask the experts tomorrow. I will let you know their answer.

  8. Kate St. Johnon 04 Jun 2014 at 11:05 pm

    Maureen, that’s so cool! Looking forward to the answer.

  9. Maureen Hobmaon 05 Jun 2014 at 9:50 am

    The fungus is Armillaria or Honey fungus

  10. Kate St. Johnon 05 Jun 2014 at 11:14 am

    Thanks, Maureen. See my update — with the answer — at the end of the blog.

Comments RSS

Leave a Reply