8 December 2022
Back in 2015 I blogged about a Corvid called a red-billed chough (Pyrrhocorax pyrrhocorax) using the title Crows with Red Beaks? The chough (pronounced “chuff“) occurs on mountains and coastal cliffs from the west coasts of Ireland and Britain to southern Europe, North Africa, Central Asia, India and China. It is often found in the Himalayas but never seen in North, South, or Central America.
However, in the past seven years, 41 North American readers have commented that they have seen a chough in their neighborhood. Sometimes I reply with the unlikeliness of the sighting and in June 2018 I updated the article with suggestions on what they might have seen instead.
A wild chough in the Americas is such rare bird sighting that it would have made international birding news, like the sighting of a Steller’s sea eagle in Maine. Even so the chough sighting comments keep coming in, including two just last month. Still no news though.
Read the original posting and comments at the link below. What do you think they’ve seen? I’m stumped.
(photo from GBIF.org via iNaturalist, map from eBird; click on the captions to see the originals)
SO INTERESTING! All the people who thought they saw a chough, and are quite sure of it. What the heck ARE they seeing? Turkey vultures? European starling? Crows who have dipped their bills in red paint or blood? We need to put these people in touch with their local Rare Bird Alert, so we can get confirmation by an expert.
Common Gallinule perhaps?
Good idea. I hadn’t thought of that one.
Just saw what I sincerely believe was a crow with a red beak. It chased aggressively chased two crows off my neighbors roof and flew over and landed on the top limb of a Weeping Alaska Cedar. I watched it closely for about 40 seconds and went in to get my Nikon which was about 12’ away, returned and and it flew in west into the woods behind my home. It was about the same size of a crow and very clearly had a red beak. No mistake over what I viewed. Best